| Boys |
| 2009 | Bryan Spreitzer, Ryan Walling |
| 2008 | Doug Black, Zak Roshdy |
| 2007 | Doug Black, Zak Roshdy, Bryan Spreitzer, Ryan Walling |
| 2004 | Andy Hrnicek, Chris Johnson (2nd team), Alex Warren |
| 2003 | John Copp (3rd team), Andy Hrnicek (2nd team), Chris Johnson (3rd team), Xavier Rutz, Alex Warren (2nd team) |
| 2002 | Matt Callahan (2nd team), Nick Stump (2nd team), Alex Warren (2nd team) |
| 2001 | Xavier Rutz |
| Girls |
| 2009 | Erica Amatori, Maura McDonnell, Jessica Rossabi |
| 2008 | Sarah Alexander, Jessica Rossabi |
| 2005 | Megan Brower (2nd team), Shannon Cox (2nd team), Brittany Johnson, Christine Truesdale (2nd team) |
| 2004 | Brittany Johnson (2nd team), Mary Ann Rutz, Brittany Smith |
| 2003 | Brittany Johnson (2nd team), Sarah Rivers, Mary Ann Rutz, Brittany Smith |
| 2002 | Sarah Rivers (2nd team), Mary Ann Rutz (2nd team), Meredith Urban (2nd team) |
| 2001 | Mary Ann Rutz |
| Boys |
| 2009 | Ben Girodias, Joe Hagan, Brendan Smith, Bryan Spreitzer, Ryan Walling, Matt Wilkie |
| 2008 | Stephan Baulch, Doug Black, Joe Hagan, Scott Hefner, Zak Roshdy, Ryan Walling, Matt Wilkie |
| 2007 | Doug Black, Brian Pahle, Zak Roshdy, Michael Santry, Bryan Spreitzer, Ryan Walling |
| 2006 | Doug Black, Adam Hrnicek, Brian Pahle, Zak Roshdy, Nate Youd |
| 2005 | Adam Burk, Andy Hrnicek, Chris Johnson, Trent Womble, John Zemonek |
| 2004 | Andy Hrnicek, Chris Johnson, Alex Warren |
| 2003 | Adam Burk, John Copp, Jon Darville, Andy Hrnicek, Chris Johnson, Xavier Rutz, Alex Warren |
| 2002 | Brian Bruce, Matt Callahan, John Copp, Chris Johnson, Xavier Rutz, Alex Warren, Russell Warriner |
| 2001 | Matt Callahan, Xavier Rutz |
| Girls |
| 2009 | Sarah Alexander, Erica Amatori, Olivia Enright, Maura McDonnell, Lauren Riedle, Jessica Rossabi |
| 2008 | Sarah Alexander, Lauren Colberg, Olivia Enright, Carly Roos, Julie Ross, Jessica Rossabi, Sarah Wilt |
| 2007 | Jessica Brunelle, Shannon Cox, Kay Keung, Christine Truesdale, Sarah Wilt |
| 2006 | Felicity Brower, Megan Brower, Jessica Brunelle, Megan Cox, Shannon Cox, Katie Sparrow, Morgan Youd |
| 2005 | Megan Cox, Shannon Cox, Brittany Johnson, Christine Truesdale |
| 2004 | Ali Brown, Laura Ecklund, Brittany Johnson, Brittany Smith, Christine Truesdale |
| 2003 | Laura Ecklund, Brittany Johnson, Sarah Rivers, Mary Ann Rutz, Brittany Smith, Lauren Svitanek |
| 2002 | Loren Edwards, Sarah Rivers, Mary Ann Rutz, Meredith Urban |
| 2001 | Bethany Baker, Kaitlin Hickman, Lisa Jackyra, Mary Ann Rutz |